Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
[x]

deviantART

 
About Me Member Photo Manipulator ondraedan23/Male/United States Recent Activity Deviant for 6 Years
Needs Premium Membership
Statistics 73 Deviations
538 Comments
4,115 Pageviews

Wow, that's powerful! :+fav:

Wed Mar 21, 2007, 5:32 AM
I've never written in my journal before, and it sucks that my first entry is a rant, but I need to get this off my chest. Yesterday while browsing, I found a "photomanipulation" that used stock from an excellent stock resource here at DA. The new author had resized the original photo, softened it up a bit with some blur and layering effects, and colorized the lighting differently. That's it. Oh wait, he also inserted some song lyrics into the description. Meanwhile, the deviation is racking up the favorites, every mindless lamb that wanders by has to stop and say "OH, SOOO POWERFUL!!1!"
So I check out the guy's gallery and he's got some really good, really original stuff, but also several more that are just stocks with overlays.

The dude's got 30,000+ page views.

Obviously this pisses me off. Not just this guy, because I've seen much worse, but the idea of some of the most popular submitters here throwing together sub-par submissions with awful blending or little to no creative use of stock. Meanwhile, guys like me (yes, this is about my own selfishness) and hundreds of other unknowns are out there working to get every aspect of each deviation as perfect as we can, with little more than a nod from a handful of thoughtful members. I hate to leave the impression that I submit solely for praise of other members, but feedback is important, and yeah, it feels good to have an image commented on and favorited.

This issue can not be fixed by talking to the artists. I called my guy on his submission and all he did was throw some sarcasm at me and then block me from commenting further. We need to be more aware when we're commenting. Don't just say "Oh that's pretty!" Don't you dare let the artist off that easy. Look at it critically. Look at the blending work. Look at the perspectives. Look at the lighting, the brushwork, and for goodness sake people, look at the original stocks.

  • Mood: Sickened
  • Listening to: Damien Rice. But this is not his fault. =)

deviantID

Devious Info

  • Current Residence: NY State
  • Interests: Snowboarding
  • Favourite style of art: Photomanipulation
  • Operating System: WinXP Home
  • MP3 player of choice: WMP
http://www.thecureforcommon.com

deviantART Community Board

[x]

Comments


:icondudenutty5:
thanx for the comment
:icontsukasaxen:
Thanks for the wonderful comment man. :)
:iconnoiseallaround:
thx for fave!:)

--
"Over the years I have come to the conclusion that it doesn't matter what instrument [of photography] you use. It's the eye behind it and the brain, I hope"
<Eve Arnold>
:iconannmei:
Thanks for the fav:)
:icondkotasromance:
Wow, so I saw you used my stock and decided to just browse your gallery for the hell of it. I must say....you are INCREDIBLE. I wish I had a fraction of the talent that you have.
:iconhandonfire:
Thanks for the Fav!
:iconcsnyder:
i love your gallery and thank you for the fave
it is appreciated

Site Map